Dear Jean Claude:
Here are some facts about the Indian situation. All
journals published by the Indian National Science
Academy and the Indian Academy of Sciences are now OA.
Both these Academies receives grants from the
Government of India (through the Department of Science
and Technology). The Council of Scientific &
Industrial Research publishes about a dozen journals
from its NISCAIR office in New Delhi. As far as I know
none of them is open access and in fact all of them
are print journals with a subscription price.
A private firm called MedKnow Publications undertakes
to publish medical journals, mostly owned by
professional societies. Right now they have more than
thirty OA titles (although the print version may have
a subscription price). The National Informatics
Centre, another Government Department, manages the
Indian Medlars Centre. This centre also publishes more
than thirty OA journals (not owned by them). Besides,
NIC-Indian Medlars Centre has set up an archive for
full text biomedical research papers and it has more
than 600 papers. But the best known Indian archive is
the one at the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore.
It has more than 2,000 papers. The National Chemical
Laboratory in Pune has a repository, but they are
concentrating on uploading Ph D theses. The National
Institute of Technology at Rourkela has an archive
with about 150 papers.
For a vast country, what we have achieved so far is
miniscule. Close to 75% of research is funded by the
Central (Federal) Government in Delhi, and yet most
Indian research papers are not easily accessible to
other Indian researchers. Open archiving is perhaps
the best solution and the government departments that
fund research have not yet come forward to mandate
self-archiving. It is likely that the University
Grants Commission which kind of oversees the
universities may come up with an OA policy soon.
Regards.
Arun
--- Jean-Claude Guédon
<jean.claude.guedon_at_UMONTREAL.CA> wrote:
> Dear Jan,
>
> Indeed, you have missed something.
>
> After our long discussion, Stevan and I, support was
> defined as follows:
>
> 1. Direct transfer of funds to a journal through
> some governmental or
> para-governmental body (e.g. a Council, a publicly
> supported university,
> etc.)in the form of direct subsidies (e.g. the 140+
> journals directly
> supported by the Social Science and Humanities
> Research council of
> Canada);
>
> 2 Indirect support, i.e. free access to space,
> equipment and work time
> within a publicly supported institution (King and
> Tenopir mention this
> as hidden form of publishing support and some
> publishers have even
> deemed it "unfair" competition...
>
> Stevan raised the very point you mentioned in yet
> another attempt brush
> aside as marginal or irrelevant the possibility of
> mandating certain
> categories of publicly-supported journals to OA. I
> have made it clear in
> my response that I keep the form of "support" you
> mention out of the
> discussion: it really relates to the seller-customer
> relationship. I
> would also include in this non-public support the
> direct transfer of
> publishing fees (instead of a subscription fee) -
> e.g. the $3,000 fee
> practised your new employer.
>
> My point was *not* to try showing that commercial
> journals are publicly
> supported; my point was to demonstrate that, in many
> countries, a (often
> overwhelming) majority of journals are supported by
> public subsidies,
> either directly or indirectly. Because of this, I
> argue they can be
> mandated by governments to go OA. Incidentally,
> Stevan agreed with this
> proposition (while still maintaining that it touched
> only a small number
> of largely irrelevant or inferior journals).
>
>
> Le samedi 17 septembre 2005 à 18:17 +0100, Jan
> Velterop a écrit :
> > I've clearly missed something. Whence this
> discussion? Is there a
> > problem? One could easily make the case that *all*
> scholarly journals
> > are supported by public money. If not directly,
> then certainly
> > indirectly, as all journals get a substantial part
> of their revenues
> > (often the majority) from publicly funded
> institutions, who pay for
> > the subscriptions, licences, page charges,
> reprints, and the like.
> >
> > That's true for many industries, though. Think of
> road construction,
> > and, dare I say it, arms manufacturing.
> >
> > Jan Velterop
> >
> > On 17 Sep 2005, at 15:20, Jean-Claude Guédon
> wrote:
> >
> > > A member of the library of the Academy of
> science of China has
> > > responded
> > > to my query about public support of journals in
> her country. here is
> > > what she had to say:
> > >
> > > As far as we know, all the scholarly journals in
> China may more or
> > > less
> > > receive public support. Editorial office of the
> scholarly journals are
> > > always affiliated to a certain institute, school
> or society, which
> > > makes
> > > them more credible to readers. The institute,
> school or society would
> > > devote part of their budget supporting the
> journals. Nowadays more and
> > > more journals are turning to self-financing, but
> they still receive
> > > public support in the form of space, equipment
> or work-time of
> > > employees.
> > >
> > > Consequently, the case of China appears clear:
> all or nearly all
> > > scholarly publications in China receive some
> form of public support.
> > >
> > > In all three cases thus far surveyed - Canada,
> Chile, China - we
> > > find a
> > > majority of journals supported by public money.
> From Chile, we hear
> > > that
> > > the Chilean situation is replicated across the
> whole continent.
> > >
> > > If this is a marginal phenomenon, we must
> redefine the word
> > > "marginal"...
> > >
> > > jcg
> > >
> > >
> > > --
> > > Dr. Jean-Claude Guédon
> > > Dept. of Comparative Literature
> > > University of Montreal
> > > PO Box 6128, Downtown Branch
> > > Montreal, QC H3C 3J7
> > > Canada
> > >
> --
> Dr. Jean-Claude Guédon
> Dept. of Comparative Literature
> University of Montreal
> PO Box 6128, Downtown Branch
> Montreal, QC H3C 3J7
> Canada
>
___________________________________________________________
How much free photo storage do you get? Store your holiday
snaps for FREE with Yahoo! Photos
http://uk.photos.yahoo.com
Received on Sun Sep 18 2005 - 17:06:47 BST