Re: Recent Comments by Albert Henderson
on Wed, 24 Jan 2001 Greg Kuperberg <greg_at_MATH.UCDAVIS.EDU> filed the
following compaint about the facilities at the University of California:
> On Tue, Jan 23, 2001 at 09:42:13PM -0500, Albert Henderson wrote:
> > Thank you for asking. You will find them in ELECTRONIC
> > DATABASES AND PUBLISHING (Transaction 1997 ISBN 1-56000-967-5)
> > which I compiled from articles that I edited in PUBLISHING
> > RESEARCH QUARTERLY. The most interesting summary statistics>
> > are to be found in the article by Richard Kaser of NFAIS.
>
> Entirely apart from whether or not I agree with you, it's not convenient
> for me to read any of your articles in the form that you publish them.
> Some UC campuses have PRQ, but UC Davis cancelled its subscription in
> 1994. It does subscribe to Society magazine, but I haven't been to the
> library in months because the Internet is more convenient. It's hardly
> worth it for me to to bicycle to the library, walk through the aisles,
> and then bicycle back, which takes about a half hour, just for a single
> article that I might skim for 15 minutes. The UC card catalog mentions an
> on-line version of Society, but only Riverside subscribes, and the URL
> seems to be broken anyway. I found another on-line avenue to Society
> with some non-trivial detective work, but it doesn't have your article
> yet and gaining access is complicated. Your book, *Electronic databases
> and publishing*, is also in the UC card catalog, but it isn't at the
> Davis campus either.
>
> In my opinion, the inadvertent self-censorship of the conservatives is
> as convincing as any direct argument that information wants to be free.
> Stevan and I may disagree strongly on how to best "liberate" the scholarly
> literature. But in keeping with our common ground, everything that we
> have written lately is freely available on the Internet. More people
> would read you if you followed our example.
Well, this is not news. The University of California is
notorious for having forsaken knowledge assets in the
recent decades. The Scripps Insitute of Oceanography
has pleaded valiantly to keep its library on a part
with its East Coast rival. Leon Litwak, writing of
his experience on the academic senate at Berkeley, has
suggested the condition of the library drives away
potential applicants.
Meanwhile, UC blithely reaps more than fifty cents
for every dollar spent on research with its claims
of overhead costs. While "Library" is a specific
allocation under the regulations governing research
overhead, there seems to be no connection between
overhead reimbursements and library spending -- or
even between the rise of academic R&D and efforts
to conserve its output.
You are not alone. Universities across the country
have undermined their faculty and researchers by
creating a bottleneck, by cutting library spending
while adding to profits and administrative growth,
by abusing librarians who are their economic
captives and by blowing off faculty governance. The
most outrageous aspect of this quiet campaign has not
been the acceptance of research sponsorship while
underminging its effectiveness. It has not been the
attitude that knowledge is not the responsibility of
the institution. It has been the avoidance of
responsibility for your problem by university managers
since 1970, when they deliberately changed their
pattern of spending.
You have my sympathy. Stevan will probably censor
my posting, as he often does with the claim that
it is irrelevant. To me, the issues of spending
and responsibility go to the heart of your problem.
I will mail you some reprints of my writings that
have survived the review of journal editors.
In the meantime, you might be interested to read
my guest editorial in SCIENCE (289:243 2000). The
online version features tables on the profits of
private universities and the reveral of fortunes
in profits and library spending of higher education
over recent decades. If you are really interested
in the statistics of my book, you can probably order
a copy through interlibrary loan without mounting
your bicycle.
Best wishes,
Albert Henderson
Former Editor, PUBLISHING RESEARCH QUARTERLY 1994-2000
<70244.1532_at_compuserve.com>
Received on Wed Jan 03 2001 - 19:17:43 GMT
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.0
: Fri Dec 10 2010 - 19:45:59 GMT